cekoni wrote:You forgot that 2 judges (which scores, by some "strange combination of circumstances the computer chose" to enter into summary marks) - put him on 21 and 22 place in SP?! ... and because that Plushy got, AT LEAST, 4-5 points less for SP!!!
You kept repeating that his choice of music affect on his success .... but I kept repeating you that it is a matter of the ISU "politics"!
clairdelalune wrote:The question was stupid because jumps are not Chan´s forte, he is way more dangerous in other areas.cekoni wrote:You forgot that 2 judges (which scores, by some "strange combination of circumstances the computer chose" to enter into summary marks) - put him on 21 and 22 place in SP?! ... and because that Plushy got, AT LEAST, 4-5 points less for SP!!!
You kept repeating that his choice of music affect on his success .... but I kept repeating you that it is a matter of the ISU "politics"!
On the TV of my house I did not see any ISU politics, only Evgeni skating to a bad program, to a music that he didn´t seem to enjoy, to a choreography which had no conexion to the music. I don´t need ISU or Joe Inman to tell me how many points Evgeni deserved for that program because I can estimate it myself. If Evgeni´s choreographhers feel they are not able to design a good program using a particular music, Evgeni should change it. That´s the relation between music and low score.
lovplush wrote:clairdelalune wrote:The question was stupid because jumps are not Chan´s forte, he is way more dangerous in other areas.cekoni wrote:You forgot that 2 judges (which scores, by some "strange combination of circumstances the computer chose" to enter into summary marks) - put him on 21 and 22 place in SP?! ... and because that Plushy got, AT LEAST, 4-5 points less for SP!!!
You kept repeating that his choice of music affect on his success .... but I kept repeating you that it is a matter of the ISU "politics"!
On the TV of my house I did not see any ISU politics, only Evgeni skating to a bad program, to a music that he didn´t seem to enjoy, to a choreography which had no conexion to the music. I don´t need ISU or Joe Inman to tell me how many points Evgeni deserved for that program because I can estimate it myself. If Evgeni´s choreographhers feel they are not able to design a good program using a particular music, Evgeni should change it. That´s the relation between music and low score.
Maybe you are really an expert on this which I am not. So I would not argue with your opinion on PCS Plushy deserved for his performance in 2010. I only know that many Chinese fans including myself fell in love with his skating because of 2010 olympics.
From whose point of view you drew the conclusion that Plushy does not like the music? Plushy has the reputation from the past that he will not use a music that he could not feel. As for the interpretion of the music, that is really very personal thing. Of course your opinion might be well aligned with the judges, but that does not mean the whole program is a total disaster. Your comments I think are kind of insults to the choreographer and to Plushy.
It was a hasty season back then and the program might well be improved for sure. That is why now we all should be patient to wait for Plushy to improve himself gradually to the next Olympics.
We will have to wait until Plushy shows his programs in the real competition. And even by then, remember that he still has 2 or 3 years to come with a master piece for 2014!!
cekoni wrote:P.S.S. clairdelune... you increasingly change your mind, after spent to many time reading FSU, IFS, GS and etc forums
let`s talk wrote:^ Good one. One detail: Mroz did a 4lutz. The 4flip was landed by Takahashi but only in a warm-up, not in the competition itself.
clairdelalune wrote:cekoni wrote:P.S.S. clairdelune... you increasingly change your mind, after spent to many time reading FSU, IFS, GS and etc forums
I'm incorruptible, Cekoni!!!!
Вера wrote:Плющенко работает пока без четверных прыжков
http://news.sport-express.ru/2011-11-20/476881/
Return to Всё о Жене || Everything about Evgeni
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 67 guests